To choose a shingle color for a Colorado Springs home, you should start with the parts of the house you will not change: brick, stone, stucco and siding. Pick a roof that shares an undertone with them (warm browns and tans with warm stone, cool grays and blacks with gray or white siding), confirm the color with your HOA or, in the Old North End, the city’s historic overlay review, then narrow to two choices and look at real shingle samples outside in daylight before you sign. A roof lasts decades and is hard to repaint, so the house should drive the choice, not the swatch.
Step 1: Start with what is permanent
Your stone, brick and stucco set the palette. Pull a color from them rather than from the trim, which you can repaint later.
- Warm stone or red brick: brown blends, cedar tones and warm grays. Avoid shingles with strong red or orange undertones next to red stone; they compete.
- Gray or white stucco, white siding: charcoal, black and cool gray blends. A black roof over white stucco is a classic look in older Colorado Springs neighborhoods.
- Painted siding you plan to change: pick a neutral blend now, because a bold roof narrows every future paint choice. If you are repainting at the same time, see our Colorado Springs exterior painting page.
Step 2: Check the rules before you fall in love
HOAs. Many Colorado Springs neighborhoods have covenants that limit roof colors, and some list approved products. Get the approval in writing before your contractor orders material, and name a second choice in case the first is rejected or back-ordered.
Historic Preservation Overlay. In the City of Colorado Springs Historic Preservation Overlay zone, which includes the Old North End historic district, the city asks owners to contact its Development Review Enterprise office at (719) 385-5982 for re-roofing, and it has a Re-Roof Report of Acceptability application. Exterior changes visible from the street that need a building permit there go through review first.
Code. Color is not a code item, but the product is. The Pikes Peak Regional Building Department requires a Class A roof covering on one- and two-family homes in the City of Colorado Springs, so whatever color you choose comes in a Class A product line. Our Colorado Springs roofing codes article covers the rest.
Step 3: Think about light, distance and roof size
Shingle colors are blends of granules, and the blend reads differently at 60 feet than in your hand. Bright Colorado sun washes colors out at midday and deepens them in the evening. Two practical rules:
- Large or steep roofs show more color, so a strong blend looks stronger. A subtle blend often looks better on a big two-story home.
- Low ranch roofs show less, so a little more contrast can help.
Dark roofs absorb more heat than light ones. On most attic-vented homes that is a comfort and ventilation question, not a reason to rule out dark colors; ask us to check your attic ventilation during the inspection.
Step 4: Narrow the list with real tools
Owens Corning suggests a three-stage approach: try colors on a photo of your own house with its Design EyeQ visualizer, compare printed shingle color posters against your siding and trim, then look at an actual product sample from your contractor before deciding. You can browse the current Owens Corning lineup on our Owens Corning color selector. Owens Corning named Summer Harvest its 2027 Shingle Color of the Year, if you want a starting point for a warm blend.
Step 5: Look at real roofs nearby
Drive your neighborhood and note roofs you like, at different times of day. A color that works on a house with similar stone or siding on your street is the best preview you can get. Ask us for photos of finished roofs in that color.
Step 6: Lock it in on the contract
Write the manufacturer, product line and color name on the contract, along with your second choice. If insurance is paying, the color is still your decision; product upgrades should be priced separately so the claim scope stays accurate. Our shingle style options in Colorado Springs page explains the product lines, and choosing between asphalt and metal covers the bigger material decision. New gutters change the look too; see choosing a gutter system, and our roofing terms glossary explains words like “blend” and “ridge cap”.
Bring samples to your free inspection
Integrity Roofing and Painting is veteran-owned and family-run since 1990, and an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred contractor with 650+ Google reviews. We bring real samples to your house so you can see them against your own siding. Call our Colorado Springs office at (719) 488-2800 or book a free Colorado Springs roof inspection, and we will reach out the same business day.
Sources: City of Colorado Springs, Historic Preservation Board review and re-roofing in the Overlay zone; Pikes Peak Regional Building Department, Reroof Guidelines, rev. 03/05/2024; Owens Corning, Design EyeQ roof visualizer and shingle color posters.
Photos From Our Projects
