Integrity Roofing and Painting
Insurance Guide

Liberty Mutual Hail Claim Stuck After a Colorado Springs Hailstorm? What to Do Next

This page started as our 2016 letter about a Liberty Mutual claim that sat for a month. The steps work with any insurer.

Veteran-owned Family-run since 1990 650+ Google reviews

Key numbers

103 verified hail storms with stones of 1.5 inches or larger reached El Paso County, which includes Colorado Springs, from 2000 to 2025 in the storm records we keep; the largest measured 4.5 inches (softball size) on July 13, 2011 (NOAA NCEI).

Hail storms by decade, 2000 to 20252000s: 35, 2010s: 44, 2020s: 24
Source: Storm library: El Paso County hail history
Largest hail4.5 in. (softball), July 13, 2011
Source: NOAA NCEI
Costliest hail storm$352.8 million insured losses (2016 dollars), July 28, 2016
Source: RMIIA
$1356.4 millionNOAA lists 'Severe Storms and Hail (June 1984)' (1984-06-13 to 1984-06-17) among billion-dollar disasters affecting Colorado, at $1356.4 million CPI-adjusted ($446.2 million unadjusted).
Source: NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information (NCEI), 1984
100.8%Colorado home insurance costs rose 100.8% from 2020 to 2025, the steepest increase in the U.S., per LendingTree.
Source: FOX21 News Colorado, 2020-2025
318NOAA's Storm Events Database logged 318 hail reports in Colorado in 2017, including 34 of 2 inches or larger.
Source: NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information (NCEI), 2017

A storm counts when the library lists El Paso County among the areas it hit. Each hail size is the storm's largest report, which may have fallen in a neighboring county, and insured losses cover every area the storm hit.

The next steps for a Liberty Mutual hail claim stuck after a Colorado Springs hailstorm are to put the request in writing, ask for a written reason and a decision date, protect the roof from further damage while you wait, and escalate through the adjuster’s supervisor and then the Colorado Division of Insurance if nothing moves. Colorado law bars insurers from unreasonably delaying payment of a covered benefit (C.R.S. 10-3-1115), and the claim stays yours throughout.

Why this page exists

After the July 28, 2016 storm, when NWS Pueblo recorded widespread baseball-sized hail in Colorado Springs and claims passed $350 million, we waited more than 4 weeks for a response to a supplement on one Liberty Mutual claim. Materials were taking about 6 weeks to arrive and winter was coming. We published our letter at the time. This version keeps the useful part: what a homeowner can do when any insurer goes quiet.

Step by step when a supplement stalls

  1. Get the facts in writing. Ask for the adjuster’s name, direct line and claim number, and email a short summary of what was submitted and when. Under C.R.S. 10-4-110.8, a Colorado homeowner can request a copy of the policy, and the insurer has 3 business days to provide it.
  2. Ask for an itemized answer. The Colorado Division of Insurance tells homeowners to ask the adjuster for an itemized explanation of the settlement offer, and to get a written letter explaining the reason for any denial.
  3. Protect the roof. Do not let a paperwork delay become a leak. Get temporary protection installed and keep every receipt; the Division also advises homeowners to limit further damage.
  4. Escalate inside the company. If the adjuster does not respond, ask for a supervisor or claims manager and repeat the written summary.
  5. File a complaint. The Colorado Division of Insurance takes consumer complaints at 303-894-7490. A complaint often gets a stalled file looked at.
  6. Know your formal options. If you disagree with the amount, your policy’s appraisal clause may apply; see how the insurance appraisal process works. For a denial, read your options when an adjuster denies roof damage.

What a strong supplement includes

  • Photos of each missed item, taken during tear-off where possible (extra layers, rotted decking, damaged flashing).
  • Measurements and quantities that match the estimate’s line items.
  • The code reason when work is required by the building department. In the Pikes Peak region that includes removing every old layer of roofing, drip edge at the eaves and rakes, and an ice barrier above 7,000 feet.
  • A clear list of what changed from the first estimate.

Our role is documentation: we photograph and measure so nothing gets missed in the scope. We do not negotiate your claim; Colorado bars roofers from acting as public adjusters. More on that line in your rights on a Colorado storm claim.

Before the next storm

Check how exposed your roof is to hail, and if a storm hits, follow what to do after storm damage. When you hire, use our checklist for choosing a hail roofer.

Integrity Roofing and Painting is veteran-owned and family-run since 1990, an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred contractor with 650+ Google reviews. Call (719) 488-2800 or book a free inspection for hail damage repair; we reach out the same business day.

Sources: C.R.S. 10-3-1115, 10-4-110.8 and 6-22-105 (unofficial reproduction); Colorado Division of Insurance, hail consumer advisory (May 22, 2024); NWS Pueblo, 2016 annual climate summary; PPRBD Reroofing Guidelines (rev. 03/05/2024).

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplement on a roof insurance claim?

A supplement is a request to add items the first estimate missed or underpriced, such as drip edge, extra layers found during tear-off, damaged decking, or code-required work. It is backed by photos and measurements and goes to the adjuster for review. The claim and the decision stay between you and your insurer.

How long can a Colorado insurer take to answer a supplement?

Colorado law does not set a fixed number of days for supplements, but C.R.S. 10-3-1115 bars an insurer from unreasonably delaying or denying payment of a covered benefit, meaning a delay without a reasonable basis. If weeks pass with no answer, ask in writing for the reason and a decision date.

Should I wait for the supplement before replacing my roof?

Do not leave the roof unprotected while you wait. Your policy expects you to limit further damage, so get temporary protection in place and keep receipts. Whether to start the full replacement before a supplement is approved is a decision to make with your insurer and your contractor, in writing.

Can my roofer call the insurance company for me?

A roofer can send documentation and talk with the adjuster about the scope of the work under a valid contract, but in Colorado a roofer may not act as a public adjuster or negotiate the claim for you. If you want someone to represent you, that is a licensed public adjuster or an attorney.

Make Sure Nothing Gets Missed in Your Claim Scope

We inspect and photograph every bit of damage so you can see exactly what belongs in the scope of your claim. We'll reach out the same business day.

Veteran-owned Family-run since 1990 Owens Corning Platinum 650+ Google reviews No obligation Financing available

Prefer to talk? Call (719) 488-2800

Request Sent!

Thanks. We'll review your request and reach out with the next step. For faster help, call (719) 488-2800.

We'll reach out the same business day. Your info stays with us, never sold or shared.