Key numbers
Areas of Colorado's Front Range and Eastern Plains can see 10 or more days of severe hail per year on average (Claims Journal, 2017).
| $3 to $25 | The Colorado Division of Insurance estimates wildfire mitigation could save homeowners only $3 to $25 a year on premiums, versus $82 to $387 for hail mitigation. Source: Colorado Division of Insurance, 2025-2026 (DOI analysis) |
|---|---|
| 7,500 | In Colorado State University burn tests at 7,500 feet, plywood charring under Class A asphalt shingles was about three times the area under metal roofing, and about twice under synthetic shake. Source: Colorado State University / EPiC Series in Built Environment, 2021 |
Insurance may not pay to replace a hail-dented metal roof in Colorado Springs. Hail usually dents metal roofs without making them leak, and many homeowners policies only pay for damage that lets water in or shortens the roof’s life. If your policy carries a cosmetic damage exclusion, a roof that looks beaten after a storm but still sheds water may not be replaced. A 2024 Colorado Division of Insurance report lists cosmetic damage exclusions among the ways insurers have responded to hail losses here. So before you choose metal in Colorado Springs, read your policy, or plan to live with dents. Our cosmetic damage exclusion explainer shows how to find the endorsement and what to ask your agent. For most homes in hail zones, we recommend a Class 4 impact-resistant shingle instead, or metal as an accent.
Cosmetic vs functional damage
| Functional damage | Cosmetic damage | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Water can get in, or the roof’s life is shortened | The look changes; water still sheds |
| Metal examples | Punctures, torn panels, seams forced open, coating cracked to bare metal | Dents and dimples across panels and trim |
| Shingle examples | Fractured mat, punctures, granule loss exposing asphalt | Less common on shingles; hail that marks a shingle often bruises or fractures it |
| Typical claim result | Covered, subject to deductible | May be excluded if the policy has a cosmetic exclusion |
An example of how the wording reads: Texas’s approved endorsement HO-145 says, “We do not cover cosmetic loss or damage to roof coverings caused by the peril of hail,” and defines cosmetic damage as damage that alters the roof’s appearance without letting water penetrate the covering. Colorado policies use their own forms, so read yours.
Why this matters more in Colorado Springs
Hail is the storm that decides roof budgets here; see Colorado Springs hailstorms and your roof. With a shingle roof, a damaging storm usually means a covered replacement minus the deductible. With a metal roof under a cosmetic exclusion, a damaging storm can mean dented panels for the rest of the roof’s life, and a lower resale appeal, at no cost to the insurer. We have seen homeowners shocked by exactly that adjuster report.
Where metal still makes sense
- You value lifespan over appearance. Metal commonly outlasts asphalt by decades; see how long a metal roof lasts in Colorado Springs.
- Your policy pays for cosmetic damage, or you can buy that coverage.
- Accents. Standing seam over a porch, bay or low-slope section paired with Class 4 shingles on the main roof gives the look with less hail exposure.
- Textured profiles. In our experience, small dents show less on stone-coated steel than on smooth, flat panels; see steel roofing.
- Wildfire areas. Metal can be a Class A option where wood is not allowed (confirm the listing); see cedar shake fire hazards.
The Class 4 shingle alternative
A UL 2218 Class 4 shingle such as Owens Corning’s Duration FLEX costs far less than most metal, may earn an insurance discount, and when hail does damage a shingle, the damage is more likely to be the functional kind a policy covers. We explain how to run the numbers in is a Class 4 shingle worth it?
What the code requires for metal here
- Permit. A metal reroof needs a PPRBD permit, pulled by a licensed contractor unless you own and live in the home and do the work yourself.
- Inspections. Direct-to-deck metal shingles need no mid-roof inspection.
- Fire rating. Homes in the City of Colorado Springs need a Class A roof covering.
- Slope. Metal roof shingles need at least a 3:12 pitch; standing seam panels are made for lower slopes. See planning your roof’s slope.
- Timing. Metal has no heat-activated sealant strip, so it is a good fit for a year-round install.
Talk it through before you buy
Integrity Roofing and Painting installs both metal and shingle roofs in Colorado Springs. We are veteran-owned and family-run since 1990, an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred contractor with 650+ Google reviews. If your current roof has hail damage, the claim stays yours; we document the damage and make sure nothing gets missed in the scope. Call (719) 488-2800, book a free inspection, or compare metal roofing in Colorado Springs and what a metal roof costs here.
Sources: Colorado Division of Insurance, HB24-1108 report (cosmetic damage exclusions); Texas Department of Insurance, Commissioner's Bulletin B-0030-98 (endorsement HO-145); Pikes Peak Regional Building Department, Reroofing Guidelines (rev. 03/05/2024); City and County of Denver, Roofing Guide and Checklist (metal shingle slope).
Photos From Our Projects
