Key numbers
103 verified hail storms with stones of 1.5 inches or larger reached El Paso County, which includes Colorado Springs, from 2000 to 2025 in the storm records we keep; the largest measured 4.5 inches (softball size) on July 13, 2011 (NOAA NCEI).
| Hail storms by decade, 2000 to 2025 | 2000s: 35, 2010s: 44, 2020s: 24 Source: Storm library: El Paso County hail history |
|---|---|
| Largest hail | 4.5 in. (softball), July 13, 2011 Source: NOAA NCEI |
| Costliest hail storm | $352.8 million insured losses (2016 dollars), July 28, 2016 Source: RMIIA |
| About 20 | NAHB's 2007 study puts asphalt shingle roof life at about 20 years, fiber cement shingles about 25 years and wood shakes about 30 years. Source: National Association of Home Builders / Bank of America Home Equity, 2007 |
| 4.4% | 4.4% of U.S. households reported roof leaks in the 2023 American Housing Survey, down from 7.6% in 1973. Source: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), 2023 |
| 18.34 million | 18.34 million occupied U.S. homes were built in the 1970s, the most of any single decade bin in RECS 2020 (20.26 million were built before 1950). Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), 2020 |
A storm counts when the library lists El Paso County among the areas it hit. Each hail size is the storm's largest report, which may have fallen in a neighboring county, and insured losses cover every area the storm hit.
A three-tab asphalt shingle roof in Colorado Springs is usually worth a repair only when the damage is small and the rest of the roof is sound; once shingles are lifting, cracking, or losing granules across whole slopes, replacement is the better money. When it is time to replace, we recommend architectural shingles rather than new three-tab: we do not install new three-tab roofs.
How to tell which situation you are in
A repair may be enough if:
- The damage is limited to a few shingles from one wind event.
- The surrounding shingles are still flexible and sealed down.
- The roof is well short of the end of its expected life.
Plan on replacement if:
- Tabs are lifting or creased on more than one slope, a sign the seal strips have let go.
- You see bare patches or granules piling up in gutters and at downspouts.
- Hail has bruised or cracked shingles across the roof. Our storm damage repair page covers how to check.
- The repair would exceed 100 square feet, which makes it a permitted job anyway.
Why three-tab shingles struggle here
A three-tab shingle is one flat layer cut into three tabs. It has less material than a laminated architectural shingle, which means less resistance to wind uplift and to hail impact. PPRBD designs buildings in the region for a 130 mph basic wind speed, and a thinner shingle gives wind and hail less to work against before it fails. Older three-tab roofs also fade, so a patch rarely matches. Our article on why 3-tab shingles are not your best roof choice goes further, and the 3-tab vs architectural comparison shows them side by side.
What we recommend instead
- Architectural shingles for the best balance of price and performance.
- Impact-resistant architectural shingles with a UL 2218 Class 4 rating if hail is your main concern.
- Luxury shingles for a shake or slate look.
Replacing three-tab is a full tear-off: PPRBD does not allow new shingles over existing layers, so we strip the roof to the deck, repair soft decking, and build the new roof from there. See when roof replacement makes sense and our asphalt shingle roofing overview.
An honest look first
Integrity Roofing and Painting is veteran-owned and family-run since 1990. If a repair will hold, we will tell you, and if the roof needs replacing, you get Good, Better, and Best options with upfront pricing. Book a free inspection.
Sources: PPRBD, Reroof Guidelines (rev. 03/05/2024); PPRBD, Basic Design Information (updated 06/30/2026).
